5 Best graphic design services for insurance agencies (2026)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TL;DR
- ✅ Best overall: ManyPixels, from $699 a month, with print, social and web design on the entry plan.
- 💰 Best refund window: Penji, $995 a month with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
- 🏢 Best for a commercial brokerage rebrand: Design At Work, a Houston agency that works only on quotes.
- ⚠️ Kimp's roughly $699 rate lasts four months, then the Graphics plan runs $1,397. Budget for month five, not month one.
Introduction
Scroll through the Facebook pages of five independent agencies in the same state and you'll often see the same posts. Same stock family on the porch, same "Is your home ready for storm season?" graphic, same caption. That isn't laziness. Most insurance marketing platforms sell a shared content library, and every agency on the platform draws from it.
Our view: a content library keeps your feed active, but it can't make your agency look like anyone in particular. Custom design is what does that. It's also what your mailers, renewal reminders, carrier co-branded flyers and office signage need, and none of that comes in a library.
The other thing insurance design has that most industries don't is carrier rules. Put a carrier's logo on a flyer and you're working inside their brand guidelines, and some carriers want to approve the piece before it prints. So the right design partner is one that can keep a clean file system per carrier and turn a revision around the same week.
Below are five services that fit an agency budget, from design subscriptions to two insurance specialists, plus a note on where the big insurance marketing platforms fit.
What do insurance agencies actually need from a design service?
An insurance agency's design work is mostly small, recurring pieces that support renewals, referrals and cross-selling. A typical year looks like this:
- Retention and cross-sell mail: renewal reminders, "have you bundled your auto and home?" postcards, annual review letters.
- Carrier co-branded pieces: flyers and one-pagers that pair your logo with a carrier's, following that carrier's rules.
- Seasonal campaigns: storm season, open enrollment, Medicare Annual Enrollment Period (AEP), year-end business reviews for commercial clients.
- Social media graphics: custom posts that sit alongside, or replace, library content.
- Office and event print: window signage, business cards, sponsorship banners for the local Little League team.
- Promotional items: insurance card holders, calendars, pens and tote bags with your logo.
- Website graphics: quote-page banners, carrier logo strips, landing pages for a single line of business.
Here's what matters about that list: almost none of it needs strategy. It needs a designer who already knows your brand and your carriers, and who can turn a request around without a new quote every time. That's why a design subscription suits most agencies better than a project-by-project agency. See also these 10 signs your business needs a design subscription.
Prices are month-to-month rates checked in November 2026, except Kimp, last checked in October 2026. Quarterly and annual billing is cheaper with most subscriptions.
The 6 best graphic design services for insurance agencies
1. ManyPixels: custom design for every carrier co-brand, from $699
{{GENERAL_PORTFOLIO="/dev/components"}}
Starting price: $699/month (Advanced)
Model: Design subscription with daily output
Turnaround: Next business day for first drafts
ManyPixels takes the top spot because its entry plan covers everything on the list above except video. Graphic design, print, web design and illustration are all on the $699 Advanced plan, with up to 2 hours of design every business day. On a typical day that's 1-2 flyers or 2-3 social graphics.
Unlimited brands is the feature that matters most for an independent agency. Set up a brand profile for your agency, then one for each carrier co-brand you run regularly, with that carrier's logo files and rules attached. When you request "Travelers flyer for small business owners", the designer already has the right lockup and clear space rules. You get the editable source files (Adobe, Figma or Canva), so your office manager can swap a date or a phone number without coming back.
The honest limits: motion graphics and video editing start on the $1,199 Business plan, so a video-first agency should budget for that tier. And ManyPixels doesn’t print. You get print-ready PDFs to send to your printer of choice. For agencies with heavier volume, 72% of ManyPixels customers choose the Assigned Designer plan ($1,399 a month) which gives you one designer who works part-time with your brand, and therefore has the opportunity to learn every carrier rule and brand specs.
Best for: Independent agencies that want custom social, mail and co-branded pieces every week ✅
Not ideal for: Agencies that want design and printing on one invoice ❌
2. Penji: print and Canva templates, with a 30-day refund

Starting price: $995/month (Essentials)
Model: Design subscription with 2 active projects
Turnaround: 1 business day
Penji covers branding, ads, social media, email, print, packaging, presentations, infographics and Canva templates on its Essentials plan, with a project manager and unlimited brand folders. Canva templates are a good fit for agencies where producers like to edit their own social posts.
The 30-day money-back guarantee is the longest refund window on this list. If you've never used a design subscription, that's a low-risk way to find out whether one suits how your office works.
Watch the tier line for video. Short-form video, reels and motion graphics are locked on Essentials and start on Agency Partner at $1,995 a month. Penji's plan cards and its comparison table also disagree on whether web and landing page design sit on Essentials, so confirm that on a call if you need web work.
Best for: Agencies trying a design subscription for the first time 💰
Not ideal for: Agencies that want video on a sub-$1,000 budget ❌
3. Kimp: a long print list, on a promotional rate

Starting price: About $699/month for the first four months, then $1,397/month (Graphics)
Model: Design subscription with 3 active requests
Turnaround: 24 hours for simple tasks, 2-4 days for complex work
Kimp publishes one of the longest print scope lists in the category. Signage, tradeshow banners, point-of-sale pieces, vehicle wraps and Canva designs are all named on the Graphics plan, along with unlimited brands and team members. For an agency that sponsors local events and wraps a company car, that list covers a lot.
The catch is month five. The discount on Kimp's pricing page runs for the first four months, after which the Graphics plan steps up to $1,397 a month. Video sits on a separate plan. A 7-day free trial lets you test it on a real flyer first.
Best for: Agencies with a print-heavy season ahead and a short-term budget 🖨️
Not ideal for: Agencies budgeting a full year at the intro rate ❌
4. Design At Work: an insurance marketing agency for commercial brokers

Starting price: Quote only
Model: Full-service marketing agency with an insurance practice
Turnaround: Project-based
Design At Work is a Houston marketing agency with a dedicated insurance practice. It works with brokerages, commercial insurance, employee benefits and risk management firms, across specialties like D&O, workers' compensation, professional liability and surety bonds. Its services cover branding, web design, SEO, PR, email, social and print collateral including direct mail and print ads.
The case for a specialist is industry fluency. A commercial brokerage selling to CFOs needs a brand and a website that sound credible to that buyer, and an agency that has done it before won't need the basics explained. Its insurance page features a rebrand and website redesign for the brokerage Brady, Chapman, Holland & Associates.
The trade-off is cost and pace. Design At Work doesn't publish pricing, and a full-service agency is built for a rebrand or a campaign, not for next Tuesday's renewal postcard. Many brokerages use an agency like this for the identity, then a subscription for the weekly work after it.
Best for: Commercial and benefits brokerages planning a rebrand 🏢
Not ideal for: Personal lines agencies that mostly need weekly social and mail ❌
5. ITC (Zywave): design from your insurance software vendor

Starting price: Quote only
Model: Design service offered by an insurance software vendor
Turnaround: Not published
Insurance Technologies Corporation (ITC), whose TurboRater site now sits on Zywave's domain, is the company behind TurboRater and an insurance website builder. It also offers graphic design services for agencies: logo design, marketing collateral and wider agency branding, alongside its websites.
The appeal is convenience. If your agency already runs its comparative rating and website through ITC, keeping your logo and collateral with the same vendor means one fewer relationship to manage, and a website team that already has your brand files.
The page lists no prices, turnaround times or package details, only a request for a consultation. Treat it as an option to price against the others, not a default.
Best for: Agencies already using ITC's rating or website products ✅
Not ideal for: Agencies that want published prices before a sales call ❌
Where do insurance marketing platforms fit?
Insurance marketing platforms fit as a content and website layer, not as a replacement for a designer. They're excellent at keeping an agency website live and a social feed posting. They aren't built to create work that's yours alone.
Agency Revolution sells a social media add-on for $90 a month, built around a content library, AI-powered curation and automated campaigns. Advisor Evolved focuses on agency websites plus a conversion add-on called PowerPack. Both solve a real problem: a feed that goes quiet for three months looks worse than a feed of library posts.
The limit is that a library is shared by design. Every agency on the same platform can post the same graphic. The setup that works for most agencies is a platform for scheduled evergreen posts, and a designer for the pieces that should only ever carry your name: your brand, your mailers, your carrier co-brands and your local sponsorships.
How do carrier logo and co-branding rules affect your design?
Carrier and association logos come with usage rules, and some carriers require approval before a co-branded piece is published. Your designer needs those rules before they start, not after the proof goes out.
Three real examples show how much the rules vary:
- Trusted Choice: the Trusted Choice brand guide sets minimum logo sizes and, when the logo sits next to an agent's logo, spacing equal to the height of the capital "T" in the Trusted Choice logo.
- Berkshire Hathaway GUARD: its agent logo page says it may review co-branded materials before publication to stay compliant with state and federal insurance advertising rules.
- Covered California: certified agents can co-brand business cards and websites without pre-approval if they follow the brand style guide, but most other materials and media ads need approval.
In practice, three habits save a lot of back-and-forth:
- Keep a carrier folder. One folder per carrier with approved logo files, the usage guide and any approval contact. On a design subscription, this becomes a brand profile.
- Build master templates with a logo slot. A co-branded flyer template that already meets the strictest carrier's clear space rules can be reused for the others.
- Add approval time to your calendar. If a carrier reviews co-branded pieces, request the design a week or two earlier than you otherwise would.
One more point. Your designer makes the piece look right. Compliance with your state's insurance advertising rules, and with CMS rules for Medicare materials, stays with your agency. Build a review step into the workflow.
Which design service should your insurance agency choose?
Pick based on what your agency produces most in an average month:
- Mostly social, mail and co-branded flyers: ManyPixels. Daily output and unlimited brands handle multiple carriers on one plan.
- Mostly printed mail and signage: ManyPixels or Kimp for print-ready files, sent to a local printer or mail house.
- First time trying a subscription: Penji, for the 30-day refund window.
- A print-heavy season with a short budget: Kimp, as long as you plan for the full rate after month four.
- A commercial brokerage rebrand: Design At Work for the identity, then a subscription for everything after it.
- Already on ITC's software: get an ITC quote, then price it against the subscriptions above.
Captive agents are the exception. If you write for a single carrier, check its local marketing portal and approval process first, since many captive programs supply or approve most local materials.
Why insurance agencies choose ManyPixels
ManyPixels isn't an insurance marketing agency, and it doesn't pretend to be. It's the design team that keeps your agency's marketing looking like your agency, every week.
- 🎨 Unlimited brands on every plan, so each carrier co-brand gets its own profile with the right logos and rules.
- 🖨️ Print, social, web design and illustration on the $699 Advanced plan.
- ⚡ Up to 2 hours of design every business day, with first drafts the next business day.
- 📁 Full ownership of every source file, including Canva files your team can edit.
- ⏸️ Pause for $10 a month after open enrollment and keep access to your files.
👉 Explore ManyPixels plans. For a wider look at the category, see our comparison of design subscription services.
Prices can change. Always check the pricing page for current rates.
Frequently asked questions
Bottom line
For most insurance agencies, the best setup is a design subscription for the weekly work, a local printer or mail house for heavy mail, and a specialist agency only when it's time to rebrand. ManyPixels leads for ongoing custom design across every carrier co-brand, Penji for agencies that want a long refund window, and Design At Work for commercial brokerages that need a new identity.
Before you pick, count how many custom pieces your agency needs in an average month, and list every carrier logo you use. Those two numbers tell you which option fits.

Top-quality designers
A complete creative team at your fingertips: graphic designers, illustrators, motion designers and more.

Lightning-fast turnaround
Get started today and receive your first update on the next business day.

All-inclusive pricing
Unlimited requests and revisions. One flat monthly fee. No surprises.

Flexible & scalable model
No contract. Scale up and down as needed. Pause or cancel anytime.
Continue reading
Explore some of our best designs
Get inspired by a curated selection of ManyPixels work. Download the portfolio to see what our team can create.





















